Haque v Haque

[1966] ALR 553
114 CLR 98

---

Haque
vHaque

Court:

Judges: Barwick CJ
Kitto J
Menzies J
Windeyer J
Owen J

Case References:
Attorney-General v Bouwens - 150 ER 1390
Attorney-General v Meyrick - 28 ER 30
Attorney-General v Worrall - (1895) 1 QB 99
Balfour v Scott - 2 ER 1259
Central Trust and Safe Deposit Company v Snider - [1916] 1 AC 266
Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Salting - [1907] AC 449
Commissioner of Stamps (Q) v Counsell (1937) - 57 CLR 248
Commissioner of Stamps v Hope - [1891] AC 476
Darby v Darby - (1856) 3 Drew 495; 61 ER 992
Drummond v Drummond - 2 ER 1293
Duckett v Collector of Imposts - (1927) VLR 457
Ewing v Orr Ewing - (1883) 9 App Cas 34
Forbes v Steven - (1870) LR 10 Eq 178
Haque v Haque (1962) - 108 CLR 230
Harding v Commissioners of Stamps for Queensland - [1898] AC 769
Henderson v Bank of Hamilton - (1894) 23 SCR (Can) 716
Herbert v Christopherson - [1930] 1 Ch 407
Heron v Espie - (1856) 18 D 917
Howard v Miller - [1915] AC 318
Jabbour v Custodian of Absentee's Property of State of Israel - [1954] 1 All ER 145
Jerningham v Herbert - (1828) 4 Russ 388; 38 ER 851
Jones v Gibbons - (1804) 9 Ves Jun 407
Lambe v Manuel - [1903] AC 68
Lawson v Commissioners of Inland Revenue - (1896) 2 IrR 418
Livingston v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Q) (1960) - 107 CLR 411
Lysaght v Edwards - (1876) 2 Ch D 499
Macdonald v Macdonald - (1932) SC (HL) 79
McClelland v Trustees Executors and Agency Co Ltd (1936) - 55 CLR 483
Mount Albert Borough Council v Australasian Temperance and General Mutual Life Assurance Society - [1938] AC 224
New York Life Insurance Co v Public Trustee - (1924) 2 Ch 101
Payne v r - [1902] AC 552
Pipon v Pipon - 27 ER 14
Privy Council in Harding v Commissioners of Stamps for Queensland - [1898] AC 769
R v Lovitt - [1912] AC 212
Rayner v Preston - (1881) 18 Ch D 1
Re Anziani; Herbert v Christopherson - (1930) 1 Ch 407
Re Berchtold; Berchtold v Capron - (1923) 1 Ch 192
Re Colling - (1886) 32 Ch D 333
Re Fuller's Contract - (1933) Ch 652
Re Holland; Brettell v Holland - (1907) 2 Ch 88
Re Hoyles; Row v Jagg - (1911) 1 Ch 179
Re Loveridge; Drayton v Loveridge - (1902) 2 Ch 859
Re O'Neill; Humphries v O'Neill - (1922) NZLR 468
Re Ralston; Perpetual Executors and Trustees Association v Ralston - (1906) VLR 689 and
Re Ritson; Ritson v Ritson - (1898) 1 Ch 667; (1899) 1 Ch 128
Re Stokes; Stokes v Ducroz - (1890) 62 LT 176
Re Williams; National Trustees Executors & Agency Co of Australasia Ltd v Brien - (1945) VLR 213
Rodriquez v Speyer Brothers - [1919] AC 59
Royal Trust Co v Provincial Secretary-Treasurer of New Brunswick (1925) - 2 DLR 49
Tabor v Grover - (1699) 2 Vern 367; 23 ER 831
Taylor v London and County Banking Co - (1901) 2 Ch 231
Thomson v Advocate-General - 8 ER 1294
Thornborough v Baker - 36 ER 1000
Toronto General Trusts Co v r (1917) - 39 DLR 380
Toronto General Trusts Corporation v r - [1919] AC 679
Wall v Bright (1820) - 1 Jac & W 494; 37 ER 456
Wallace v Attorney-General - (1865) LR 1 Ch 1
Walsh v r - [1894] AC 144
Weston v Mowlin - (1760) 2 Burr 969
cf Brannigan v Brannigan - (1954) NZLR 858
cf Freke v Lord Carbery - (1873) LR 16 Eq 461
cf Payne v r - [1902] AC 552
cf Philipson-Stow v Inland Revenue Commissioners - [1961] AC 727
cf R. v Lovitt - [1912] AC 212
cf Re Holland; Brettell v Holland - (1907) 2 Ch 88
re Berchtold; Berchtold v Capron - (1923) 1 Ch 192
re Cutcliffe's Will Trusts; Brewer v Cutcliffe - (1940) 1 Ch 565

Hearing date: 9 and 10 September 1964
Judgment date: 29 July 1965

---

Order

Appeal dismissed with costs.