We seek feedback and advice about how we estimate the gap from our external and internal subject matter experts. Based on the advice, the reliability for this estimate is low with a score of 15.
The methodological validity of the approach is also assessed as low. The level of data and information held on the high wealth population is extensive with sufficient population coverage. However, we have seen sensitivity to extreme values having a disproportionate impact on the estimates, which is a failing of the methodology.
This year’s gap estimate incorporates the addition of long-term non-payment, which provides a better understanding for the final gap estimate. Despite this improvement, due to the sensitivity to extreme outcomes, strong reliance on assumptions made (particularly relating to non-detection) and the population data error we are unable to resolve in this year estimates, overall we decreased the rating from 20 with an assessment of medium to 15, an assessment of low.
Figure 3: Reliability rating scale – high wealth income tax gap