Core tax and compliance issues overview
When engaging with privately owned and wealthy groups (private groups), we often identify issues arising from inadequate governance, internal controls or professional advice.
Governance processes will vary according to your group’s size, structure and industry. However, all private groups should maintain complete and correct records that contemporaneously support their transactions and tax positions. This includes records of decisions and specialist advice you've obtained. As your group’s business and investment strategies evolve, your approach to identifying and managing tax risk should also evolve.
Our Tax governance for privately owned groups provides practical guidance to help you embed effective tax governance practices.
Record keeping for intra-group transactions
Private groups often operate through multiple legal entities. While these entities may have common ownership and management, it’s important to remember that transactions between entities in a private group may attract tax and be subject to specific taxing provisions. This is unless the entities are part of a:
- tax consolidated group
- multiple-entry consolidated group
- GST group.
We focus on whether intra-group transactions are supported by appropriate records and contemporaneous evidence of decisions and actions. Common ownership, management or an internal understanding between parties does not reduce record-keeping obligations, even where transactions are on commercial terms.
Areas that attract our attention include:
- intra-group transactions that aren't supported by appropriate documents (such as contracts, service agreements and invoices) that provide objective and contemporaneous evidence of decisions and arrangements
- deductions for expenses where there's insufficient evidence of a presently existing legal obligation to pay the amount
- failure to maintain appropriate records for the required period
- reliance on journal entries alone as evidence of a transaction.
Trusts
Our engagements continue to identify:
- issues where trustees haven't correctly recognised or managed the tax consequences of trust distributions
- higher-risk arrangements that result from tax planning outside the ordinary course of business or family dealings.
Trust distributions and related tax consequences
We're concerned about:
- Family trusts distributing outside the family group, which triggers family trust distribution tax (FTDT). We observe there's a lack of awareness about the compounding nature of FTDT. This is resulting in significant liabilities and general interest charge (GIC). We encourage taxpayers to self-review their trust distributions to identify and pay FTDT liabilities. We'll look favourably on this when we consider requests for GIC remission, which is available until 30 June 2027.
- Franked dividend distributions where beneficiaries of trusts claim the franking credit tax offset despite not being qualified persons. This includes where the holding period rule isn't satisfied to reduce their tax liability. We're particularly concerned about newly incorporated corporate beneficiaries that may not meet the qualified person requirement.
Higher-risk trust arrangements
We're concerned about:
- Distributions to lower-taxed beneficiaries where economic benefits flow elsewhere. This behaviour can be exploiting mismatches, inappropriately reducing trust income, or avoiding tax. For more information, see
- PCG 2022/2 Section 100A reimbursement agreements – ATO compliance approach
- TR 2022/4 Income tax: section 100A reimbursement agreements
- TA 2022/1 Parents benefitting from the trust entitlements of their children over 18 years of age.
- Trusts with significant losses, particularly where those losses have been introduced following a change in economic ownership or have arisen from overstated or unsupported expenses. This includes arrangements that seek to distribute trust income to loss trusts where the requirements for deducting those losses under Schedule 2F to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 are not satisfied, with the effect of inappropriately reducing the tax that would otherwise be payable on that income.
Lodgment obligations
Trusts that fail to keep their lodgment obligations up to date or don't lodge at all, will likely trigger compliance action from us to secure lodgment. If these obligations continue to be ignored, our compliance action will become progressively firmer, which may include audit or prosecution.
Capital gains tax (CGT)
We continue to focus on the correct application of CGT exemptions, concessions, discounts and rollovers.
We continue to identify eligibility errors and misunderstandings about when CGT concessions apply.
Incorrect treatment of assets as pre-CGT
We continue to see taxpayers claim that assets they hold qualify for the pre-CGT exemption. This is particularly the case where the asset is held by a trust, company or partnership. You need to review whether assets continue to qualify for pre-CGT treatment, particularly after ownership changes, group restructures or significant improvements to an asset.
Failure to meet eligibility conditions
We identify entities that access exemptions or rollovers without satisfying the relevant eligibility criteria. For example, an entity may claim the small business CGT concessions without meeting the small business entity test or maximum net asset value test.
Private groups should assess eligibility before applying these concessions, including:
- confirming they've met the relevant turnover or asset tests
- documenting how they've applied those tests.
CGT discount
We identify:
- beneficiaries who fail to gross up discounted gains distributed from a trust
- companies claiming the CGT discount when they're not eligible.
Use of multiple exemptions and rollovers
We identify arrangements where entities apply multiple exemptions and rollovers across a series of transactions. These arrangements may create compliance risks, particularly where they defer or reduce tax outcomes beyond the intended scope of the provisions.
Restructuring
Private groups often restructure to manage changes in the operating environment. This may involve selling a business or the introduction of new investors.
A restructure may involve several interrelated steps and trigger tax consequences, particularly where:
- ownership interests change
- trust deeds are amended
- assets are disposed of or transferred.
We focus on whether entities have:
- correctly identified and treated the tax consequences of each step
- taken steps that are unnecessary to achieve the commercial objective of the restructure.
For example, some taxpayers fail to recognise when a CGT event has occurred.
You need to:
- consider the tax consequences of each step in a restructure
- document changes appropriately
- reflect them in updates to the succession plan.
Complex or contrived arrangements may attract closer scrutiny from us, particularly where there are indicators that they have been structured to obtain a tax advantage.