The 5 pillars of compliance
The privately owned and wealthy groups (private groups) three-tier model (3TM) is comprehensive and leverages the OECD’s 4 pillars of tax compliance to consider all areas of tax performance and the tax and super laws. This means that the model covers the different ways taxpayers interact with the tax and super systems.
Increasingly, we're also focussing on third-party reporting as a ‘fifth pillar’ in its own right. Third-party reporting is reporting on the tax affairs of others. The modern tax system is increasingly relying on third-party data that taxpayers provide. This has flow-on impacts for taxpayers of all sizes and how they interact with their tax obligations.
Taxpayer behaviours identified in the 3TM are generally linked to one of the pillars of compliance:
- Registration: Are taxpayers correctly registered in the tax system?
- Lodgment: Are taxpayers lodging their forms on time?
- Correct reporting: Are taxpayers providing the right information in their forms?
- Payment: Are taxpayers paying their obligations in full and on time?
- Third-party reporting: Are taxpayers meeting their mandatory reporting obligations for transactions with third parties?
The 3 tiers and what they tell us
The model is made up of 3 tiers that drill down into the behaviours we observe for private groups:
- Tier 1 – These are the major drivers of tax performance and non-performance for these taxpayers. These behaviours are what drives improvement or deterioration in the tax gaps.
- Tier 2 – These are the visible events for Tier 1 behaviours. They can affect us achieving improvements in tax performance or preventing deterioration in the tax system.
- Tier 3 – These are the specific focus areas for each Tier 2 event. This is where we intervene to address the behaviours, but it's not an exhaustive list of all interventions.
How we use the 3TM in our decision making
By giving us a holistic view of taxpayer behaviours, the 3TM:
- enables us to focus on strategies that will help manage our areas of focus for private groups and the compliance risks that attract our attention
- supports us to reach our goal of reducing the high wealth and medium business income tax gaps and understand whether private groups are meeting their tax obligations.
The 3TM also allows us to provide transparency on where we're focussing our efforts to:
- foster strong tax performance
- prevent and address tax non-performance by private groups.
The privately owned and wealthy groups 3TM
For private groups, we’ve identified 6 behaviours driving tax performance:
- Participation in the tax system
- Meeting tax obligations
- Correct reporting and tax treatment of transactions
- Entitlement to concessions and refunds
- Structures designed to minimise tax
- Cross-border transactions and structures.
These behaviours are Tier 1 of the three-tier model. The following tables outline the events (Tier 2) and focus areas (Tier 3) for each behaviour.
Participation in the tax system (Tier 1)
Under this Tier 1 behaviour, we consider how private groups participate in the tax system by meeting their registration and lodgment obligations. There are also specific events and focus areas related to disclosing foreign income and investments, and property and construction subcontractor tax compliance.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
Registration obligations
|
|
|
Lodgment obligations |
|
|
Disclosure of foreign investments and income |
|
|
Property and construction subcontractor tax compliance |
|
Meeting tax obligations (Tier 1)
This Tier 1 behaviour considers third-party reporting, payment and employer obligations for private groups, as well as obligations for those private groups involved in the indirect tax system.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
Third party reporting obligations |
|
|
Employer obligations |
|
|
Indirect tax obligations |
|
|
Payment obligations |
|
Correct reporting and tax treatment of transactions (Tier 1)
The events and focus areas for this Tier 1 relate to correct reporting for a range of issues that impact private groups, including Division 7A, intra-group transactions and asset use, and real property transactions.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
Income, sales, deductions and credits |
|
|
Tax treatment of loans and other assets provided to private company shareholders and associates (Division 7A) |
|
|
Classification of transactions |
|
|
Tax treatment of intragroup transactions and asset use |
|
|
Tax treatment of real property transactions |
|
Entitlement to concessions and refunds (Tier 1)
Under this Tier 1, we consider how various tax concessions are accessed by private groups.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
CGT concessions and CGT rollovers |
|
|
Research and development tax incentive |
|
|
Franking credits |
|
|
Other tax concessions |
|
Structures designed to minimise tax (Tier 1)
This Tier 1 behaviour is about the ways that private groups can use various structures and arrangements to minimise the amount of tax they pay.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
Use of concessionally taxed vehicles |
|
|
Use of complex investment vehicles or arrangements |
|
|
High-risk arrangements to extract or transfer wealth |
|
|
High-risk trust arrangements |
|
|
Income and expense recognition |
|
Cross-border transactions and structures (Tier 1)
Under this Tier 1 behaviour, we consider cross-border transactions and structures used by private groups and the impacts under Australian tax law.
|
Tier 2 - Events |
Tier 3 – Focus areas |
|---|---|
|
Pricing and characterisation of offshore transactions |
|
|
International tax arbitrage |
|