Statistical methods
We use 2 bottom-up statistical methods to estimate the high wealth income tax gap, the:
- extreme value theorem regression model for individuals, and
- multi-stage logistic linear regressions model for companies.
We step through the following methods and results and combine them in Table 2 as follows.
Calculation – high wealth individuals
There are 4 steps in the extreme value theorem to estimate the high wealth individuals tax gap.
Step 1: Identify the extreme population
Amendments for high wealth individual taxpayers follow a power law distribution, with the majority of total tax amendments in value terms represented by a small number of amended income tax returns.
We rank the amendments in descending order and identify the point where the cumulative sum of positive amendments is equal to or less than the total negative amendments.
We remove all these small amendments, which have no impact on the net value of total amendments. The remaining amendments are referred to as the 'extreme values'.
We calculate the number of extreme values as a ratio of all amendments to be used for extrapolation purposes in Step 2.
Step 2: Estimate the unreported tax amount
We transform the amendment data of the extreme population to estimate a linear relationship between the value and rank of the amendments using a regression approach.
To estimate the unreported tax amount, we then extrapolate the relationship to the number of taxpayers expected to contribute to the extreme values in the wider population.
Step 3: Apply a non-detection uplift factor
We need to account for imperfections in the process that could lead to the final gap estimate not reflecting the true tax gap. To account for non-detection, we apply an uplift factor to the unreported tax amount in Step 2.
Step 4: Consolidate the gap estimates
We calculate theoretical tax by consolidating total reported with unreported and non-detection from steps 2 and 3. For expected collections we take total reported tax and subtract the long-term non-payment amounts. This year we have moved from 'Non-pursuable debt' to 'Long-term non-payment'. For more information on this method, see Payment gap.
We can then calculate the net gap by subtracting expected collections from theoretical tax and calculate the gross gap by reintroducing amendment.
Summary of the estimation process – high wealth individuals
Table notes:
* 2021–22 financial year is subject to a population error.** Projected years in Table 2.Calculation – high wealth companies
The following 5-step bottom-up regression is applied to estimate the high wealth-linked companies income tax gap.
Step 1: Establish a logistic regression trend
We analyse the income tax return data of companies that have been subject to amendment activities and adjust the data to account for selection bias. We identify the relevant characteristics of companies in general that would contribute to the prediction of whether a company has a tax gap.
Based on these characteristics, we assign each company a unique probability of having a tax gap. We then model each company to be compliant or non-compliant through a 'Monte Carlo' simulation.
Step 2: Establish a linear regression trend
We analyse tax return data of known non-compliant companies to identify characteristics of companies that would contribute to the prediction of the tax gap size. We also apply weights to account for selection bias. Then we apply linear regression to each company to estimate the potential size of the gap.
The key difference between Steps 1 and 2 is:
- Step 1 calculates the likelihood of a company having a tax gap
- Step 2 calculates the size of each company's potential tax gap.
Step 3: Combine the results from the 2 regressions
We calculate the estimated unreported tax amount for each simulation by adding the Step 2 non-compliance amount to the predicted non-compliance companies in Step 1. We estimate total unreported tax (including amendments) by taking an average of the results from 20,000 simulations.
Step 4: Apply a non-detection uplift factor
We uplift the estimates preceding this step to account for non-compliance that isn't detected. This ensures that the final estimate is not understated.
Step 5: Consolidate the tax gap estimates
We calculate theoretical tax by consolidating total reported with unreported and non-detection from steps 2 and 3.
For expected collections we take total reported tax and subtract the long-term non-payment amounts. This year we have moved from Non-pursuable debt to Long-term non-payment.
We can then calculate the net gap by subtracting expected collections from theoretical tax and calculate the gross gap by reintroducing amendment.
Summary of the estimation process – high wealth companies
|
Component |
2015–16 |
2016–17 |
2017–18 |
2018–19 |
2019–20 |
2020–21* |
2021–22 |
2022–23** |
2023–24** |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Population |
14,765 |
14,786 |
19,543 |
21,535 |
23,634 |
27,228 |
33,049 |
29,688 |
32,845 |
|
Theoretical tax |
4,001 |
4,082 |
5,892 |
5,806 |
5,906 |
7,592 |
9,410 |
7,974 |
10,001 |
|
Voluntary reported |
3,566 |
3,663 |
5,252 |
5,169 |
5,235 |
6,665 |
8,291 |
7,070 |
8,898 |
|
Add amendments |
27 |
27 |
25 |
40 |
33 |
114 |
73 |
65 |
62 |
|
Total reported |
3,817 |
3,915 |
5,628 |
5,550 |
5,635 |
7,203 |
8,957 |
7,609 |
9,561 |
|
Subtract long-term non-payment |
224 |
225 |
351 |
340 |
367 |
425 |
593 |
474 |
601 |
|
Expected collections |
3,593 |
3,690 |
5,277 |
5,209 |
5,268 |
6,779 |
8,364 |
7,135 |
8,960 |
|
Net gap ($m) |
408 |
392 |
616 |
596 |
638 |
813 |
1,046 |
839 |
1,041 |
|
Net gap (% of theoretical tax) |
10.2% |
9.6% |
10.4% |
10.3% |
10.8% |
10.7% |
11.1% |
10.5% |
10.4% |
|
Assessment gap ($m) |
184 |
167 |
264 |
256 |
271 |
389 |
453 |
366 |
440 |
|
% of theoretical |
4.6% |
4.1% |
4.5% |
4.4% |
4.6% |
5.1% |
4.8% |
4.6% |
4.4% |
|
Payment gap ($m) |
224 |
225 |
351 |
340 |
367 |
425 |
593 |
474 |
601 |
|
% of theoretical |
5.6% |
5.5% |
6.0% |
5.9% |
6.2% |
5.6% |
6.3% |
5.9% |
6.0% |
|
Gross gap ($m) |
435 |
420 |
641 |
636 |
670 |
927 |
1,119 |
904 |
1,103 |
|
Gross gap (% of theoretical tax) |
10.9% |
10.3% |
10.9% |
11.0% |
11.4% |
12.2% |
11.9% |
11.3% |
11.0% |
Table notes:
* 2021–22 financial year is subject to a population error.** Projected years in Table 3.Find out more about our overall research methodology, data sources and analysis for gap estimates at Principles and approaches to measuring gaps.
Limitations
The following caveats and limitations apply when interpreting this tax gap estimate.
There is a considerable delay between an income year and the completion of our compliance activities for that year. This means gap estimates are subject to revisions for a considerable period. Amendment results for companies are projected for 2024 and 2021–22 to 2023–24 for individuals and are subject to revisions over coming years before eventually being replaced by actual amendments.
The estimations technique used to estimate the high wealth individuals' population was chosen for its theoretical ability to handle extreme values. This is important in a population where it is plausible that singular extreme values can bias the outcome. We consider these extreme values important to capture in the estimate as they are representative of a real risk present in the population, so our method must be able to handle them.
We have an increasing concern that in practice for the Australian context, extreme values have too much influence on our estimates. Since first implementing this approach, we have also seen many of our peers in revenue estimation move away from extreme value theorem. We will be assessing the appropriateness of this method going forward with the intention to implement the most appropriate solution. This is a difficult problem to solve due to the diverse characteristics of this population, but we will be attempting to strike the right balance.
In addition, there is no independent data source that can provide a credible or reliable macroeconomics-driven estimate (unlike indirect taxes). The true extent of non-detection is unknown and extremely challenging to measure. There is also no international proxy we can apply to the individuals or companies in this population.
Updates and revisions to previous estimates
Each year we refresh our estimates in line with our annual report. Changes from previously published estimates occur for a variety of reasons, including:
- improvements in methodology
- revisions to data
- additional information becoming available.
A review of the population data identified a selection process error which inflated the 2021–22 high wealth population. While we cannot reliably quantify the impact on the 2021–22 tax gap estimate, we have confidence that the published estimates for other years remain reliable. We will correct the population selection process and review the affected estimate as part of next year’s release.
Figure 2: Current and previous net high wealth income tax gap estimates, 2013–14 to 2023–24
This data is presented in Table 4 as a percentage.
|
Program year |
2015–16 |
2016–17 |
2017-18 |
2018–19 |
2019–20 |
2020–21 |
2021–22* |
2022–23 |
2023–24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
2026 |
8.6% |
8.0% |
8.1% |
12.4% |
13.2% |
11.1% |
9.9% |
10.7% |
9.8% |
|
2025 |
11.5% |
7.3% |
6.5% |
7.3% |
8.8% |
7.2% |
6.5% |
7.2% |
n/a |
|
2024 |
9.6% |
10.4% |
7.5% |
7.3% |
7.7% |
7.2% |
6.1% |
n/a |
n/a |
|
2023 |
9.0% |
10.1% |
7.0% |
8.2% |
7.5% |
7.1% |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
|
2022 |
7.4% |
7.8% |
6.8% |
7.0% |
6.7% |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
|
2021 |
6.6% |
6.8% |
7.1% |
6.9% |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
*2021–22 financial year is subject to a population error.