Some of today’s reporting about the ATO’s use of Superannuation Guarantee nudge letters is misleading and risks causing unnecessary concern for employers and the broader community. It unfairly challenges the importance of ensuring that all employees, particularly the most vulnerable members of our community are paid their superannuation entitlements. This is a serious problem, with an estimated over $7 billion out of nearly $120 billion each year of superannuation entitlements not being paid.
To be clear, these letters do not create a debt or a demand for payment, they are not an assessment of Superannuation Guarantee obligations, they do not impose a penalty and they do not even automatically trigger an audit. As such, any comparison with Robodebt is fundamentally misplaced.
We do acknowledge the recent concerns raised about these letters and are in the process of making changes to future letters to clarify their intent, and ensure they do not cause unnecessary concern to employers who have met their superannuation obligations.
While we recognise the pressure small businesses can face, the ATO must appropriately balance the interests of employers and employees – for employees, this is to ensure they receive their superannuation entitlements in a timely way to support their retirement savings. Often an employee does not feel in a position to challenge their employer for fear of losing their job. Alternatively, the employer may be promising to pay their superannuation in the employee’s pay slips, but does not actually pay the superannuation fund.
The ATO sends these letters when information reported by employers and super funds indicates there may be a discrepancy that needs to be checked. The purpose is to give employers an opportunity to review their own records, correct any reporting errors and, where necessary, tell us about any unpaid super and check to see if they can rectify and pay before further compliance action is considered.
The amount identified in a nudge letter is therefore not a determination of an amount owed. Differences between information identified in a letter and any subsequently established liability are consistent with the purpose of the letter: to alert an employer to a potential discrepancy so they can check and, where necessary, correct it.
In 2025–26, employers who received these letters went on to disclose $467 million in unpaid super for their employees without further intervention from the ATO.
Our compliance focus remains on employers who are not meeting their obligations to pay super. When super is not paid, employees miss out not only on contributions they are legally entitled to, but also the earnings those contributions would otherwise generate. While the law also provides consequences for late payment, these cases are not our main compliance priority.
If employers need assistance or further information, please contact your tax professional or the ATO on 13 10 20.
Notes to journalists
ATO stock footage and images are available for use in news bulletins from our media centre.