Tax gap estimates
Tax gaps estimate the difference between what the ATO expects to collect and the amount that would have been collected if every taxpayer was fully compliant with relevant taxation law.
The tax gap estimates shown in the following tables and commentary are net gaps. They represent our estimate of what ultimately will be uncollected in each financial year after recognising the impact of our compliance and other activities. Our historical estimates are refreshed to account for more information, allowing for a more informed analysis of the trend in tax gap.
We group our tax gap estimates into 3 main categories:
- transaction-based taxes
- income-based taxes
- administrative programs – these do not form part of our headline tax gap estimate (see Table 3).
Recognising the public benefit of reliable and credible tax gap estimates, we continue to engage an external independent advisory group who provide advice on our estimation approaches.
Assessing tax performance
As the nation’s principal tax collector, we use tax gap estimates to inform strategies to improve tax compliance over time. We engage with a range of stakeholders to understand risks and drivers, and how we can collaborate to maximise voluntary compliance.
Assessing the performance of the tax and superannuation systems and its administration requires consideration of all our performance indicators rather than the tax gap estimates in isolation. Tax gap estimates are best viewed as a trend over time. A single point estimate is unlikely to provide sufficient insight into the performance of the system. For this reason, the entire series is updated every year.
Tax gap estimates are lag measures (typically 2 years) and even then, estimates are provisional in nature as they are based on incomplete information. It can take more than 7 years before estimates stabilise to their final estimate.
2023–24 total net tax gap estimate
For 2023–24, we estimate the net tax gap for income, transactional and excise taxes to be $72.7 billion, or 10.3% of the total theoretical tax of $707 billion.
Conceptually, the overall tax gap currently comprises the following 2 main components:
- Assessment gap – represents tax that remains unassessed due to non-registration, non-lodgment, incomplete or inaccurate reporting (or both).
- Payment gap – represents tax that is assessed but is not expected to be paid to the ATO.
The overall tax gap provides a system-level view of the difference between the tax we collect and the amount that would be collected if taxpayers fully complied with the law. Tracking this gap over time helps assess the long-run performance and health of the tax system, including changes in willing participation and material shifts in non-compliance.
The estimates identify the types and scale of revenue loss, improve transparency about the performance of the system and its administration. They help inform our decisions about priority risks, opportunities and the allocation of our resources. They are interpreted alongside other performance measures rather than as a standalone assessment of our performance.
The overall tax gap aggregates the estimated gaps for all income taxes and indirect taxes within scope. It also includes the payment gap for PAYG instalments and PAYG withholding because these amounts are recognised as credits in the corresponding income tax gaps, but not the reporting gap as this is covered in the income tax gaps.
The overall tax gap excludes the super guarantee, fuel tax and product stewardship for oil gaps because they relate to administered programs rather than tax revenue.
We publish the methodology and analysis for each tax gap at Tax gap.
Changes in 2023–24
The movement from the published 2022–23 result (last year's publication) to the 2023–24 result reflects 2 main factors:
- Deteriorating reporting of income tax – the increase primarily reflects continued deterioration in income tax reporting, mainly in the small business population and to a lesser extent in the individuals not in business and high wealth populations.
- Method changes for payment gap – introducing the new methodology for the payment gap has added around 0.5 percentage points to each year estimates compared to the previous methodology. It replaces the partial allowance for non-pursuable debt with a comprehensive estimate of the assessed tax expected to remain unpaid over the long term.
|
Tax gap |
2020–21 |
2021–22 |
2022–23 |
2023–24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Net gap (%) |
8.3 |
9.1 |
10.3 |
10.3 |
|
Net gap ($m) |
43,759 |
52,905 |
66,215 |
72,679 |
|
Assessment gap (%) |
7.6 |
8.1 |
9.5 |
9.6 |
|
Assessment gap ($m) |
39,927 |
47,181 |
61,123 |
67,612 |
|
Payment gap (%) |
0.7 |
1.0 |
0.8 |
0.7 |
|
Payment gap ($m) |
3,832 |
5,724 |
5,092 |
5,067 |
Payment gap
A significant change to our estimates this year is the introduction of the Payment gap, which estimates assessed tax expected to remain unpaid over the long term. This replaces our previous methodology for non-pursuable debt. The change in methodology adds 0.5 percentage points to this year’s tax gap result.
The payment gap itself has continued to decline from its 2021–22 peak, indicating that the increase in the overall gap is being driven by reporting performance while payment performance is beginning to return to longer run trends.
|
Year |
2020–21 |
2021–22 |
2022–23 |
2023–24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Increase in percentage points |
↑0.4 pp |
↑0.7 pp |
↑0.6 pp |
↑0.5 pp |
The new method is considered considerably more reliable and comprehensive than prior debt estimates. The payment gap is drawn from our estimate of long-term non-payment, tax and superannuation liabilities that have been reported to us but expected to remain unpaid.
Long-term non-payment is an accrual measure, which helps us understand how much revenue related to a specific income year is unlikely to be collected. This differs from the debt book measure, which reflects the total stock of outstanding debt at a point in time, regardless of the income year to which the debt relates. Additionally, long-term non-payment also only captures tax revenue and superannuation obligations and excludes penalties and interest from the estimate.
When considered alongside the gap, long-term non-payment provides a clearer picture of payment compliance behaviours, debt recovery outcomes, and the overall performance of the tax and superannuation systems.
The payment gap subcomponent is calculated by taking the sum of the long-term non-payment estimate of each listed gap and dividing this by the sum of the total theoretical liability of each listed gap. This component is new in 2025–26. While some prior year estimates of individual gaps included provision for non-pursued debt, the introduction of payment gap in all programs and tax basis allows for an overall estimate for the first time.
The following estimates use revised data and updated methods. Further detail is available at Principles and approaches to measuring gaps.
2023–24 key findings
The 3 largest components of the net tax gap are the:
- small business income tax gap
- individuals income tax gap
- GST gap.
Together these account for more than 82% or around $59.7 billion of the total tax gap.
The small business income tax gap is the largest component of the total tax gap (accounting for around 49.5% of the total gap). We estimate the small business tax gap has increased from 16.3% of theoretical revenue in 2020–21 to 20.5% in 2023–24. As this estimate represents almost half of the total tax gap, it is a significant driver of the overall tax gap estimate. We continue to focus on deliberate behaviours to avoid taxes or exploit the regulatory system, through our shadow economy funded program.
The individuals net tax gap is the second largest component of the total net gap, at 22% of the overall gap. We estimate the tax gap for individuals to be $16.0 billion in 2023–24, or 7% of the total theoretical tax, up from 6.7% in 2022–23. We continue to utilise third-party data to pre-fill tax returns, and data and analytics to prevent the overclaiming of deductions.
The GST net gap represents 10.6% of the overall net gap for 2023–24. We estimate that the GST net gap has declined from $7.8 billion (8.7% of theoretical revenue) in 2022–23 to $7.7 billion (8.3%) in 2023–24. For GST we also estimate the 2024–25 net gap, which continues to indicate a modest decline to $7.3 billion or 7.6% of theoretical revenue. We are committed to helping small businesses get it right to register for GST and report their GST transactions accurately. Additionally, recent legislative changes have allowed us more time to process refunds to detect and investigate potential fraud before a refund is issued.
We also estimate the net tax gap for pay as you go (PAYG) withholding and 4 administered programs (see Table 3). These additional estimates do not form an additional part of the overall tax gap estimate, as they are already implicitly included in other gap estimations.
We no longer publish estimates of the tobacco tax gap or include as part of the overall tax gap. The office of the Illicit Tobacco and E-cigarette Commissioner (ITEC) will provide more comprehensive reporting on the size of both the illicit tobacco and e-cigarette markets and estimates of the excise and excise-equivalent customs duty avoided.
Governance and assurance
We have a strong governance framework and assurance process over our estimation methods used in gap processes. This includes external review by an advisory panel of subject matter experts to ensure we have confidence in our tax gap estimates, and in other metrics that measure tax system performance which we report in our Commissioner of Taxation annual report.
Tax gap estimates are a lag indicator. They measure the performance of the tax system for previous years.
The assessment component of the tax gaps are about measuring what isn't directly observable – what people have not told us.
Taxpayers may not have registered, lodged or reported their true tax position:
- due to a misunderstanding of their obligations
- by choice
- by taking a tax position that differs from our view of the law.
The payment gap measures the amount of tax that people have reported to us but is unlikely to be paid.
All tax gap estimates are subject to a degree of estimation error. Estimates can change from prior years due to the availability of data, improvements in the methods we use and revisions to previous years' data, for example audits completed and assessments raised after a review.
The trends of tax gap over time provide us with:
- useful insights into the longer-term operation of the tax and superannuation systems
- information on the overall performance and integrity of the system, including levels of willing participation and significant shifts in compliance
- guidance in determining priority risks and opportunities to better inform where we need to focus to
- lock in improvements in compliance
- prevent behaviours and activities that might increase the tax gap
- reduce the overall tax gap over time.
Changes in the economy, society and technology mean the issues driving tax gaps continue to evolve. We also must be realistic and recognise that there are many factors that ultimately impact on the overall tax gap, and that some of these will be outside our control. No tax system or administration can eliminate tax gaps, as the cost of doing so would be prohibitive.
Effective tax gap management requires engagement with a range of stakeholders. Our work goes beyond estimating the tax gap. We want to understand the risks and drivers, and how we can work together with the community to sustainably improve compliance.
In this overview of tax gaps in Australia, we explain why we measure tax gaps, our approach to ensure credibility and a summary of the latest available estimates.
You can find out more about our research methodology, data sources and analysis used for our tax gap estimates in Principles and approaches to measuring gaps.
Tax gaps by category
Following are the different tax gaps we measure, which we group into 3 categories:
Transaction-based tax gaps
- Alcohol tax gap
- Fuel excise gap
- Goods and services tax gap
- Luxury car tax gap
- Wine equalisation tax gap
Income-based tax gaps
- Fringe benefits tax gap
- High wealth income tax gap
- Individuals not in business income tax gap
- Large corporate groups income tax gap
- Large super funds income tax gap
- Medium business income tax gap
- Petroleum resource rent tax gap
- Small business income tax gap
- Small super funds income tax gap
Administered program and PAYG withholding gaps
For previously published tax gap figures, see Australian Tax Gaps – Data.gov.auExternal Link