Breskvar v Wall

126 CLR 376
(1971) 46 ALJR 68
[1972] ALR 205

---

Breskvar
vWall

Court:

Judges: Barwick CJ
McTiernan J
Menzies J
Windeyer J
Owen J
Walsh J
Gibbs J

Subject References:
Real Property (Q.)
Torrens System
Indefeasibility of title
Exceptions
Fraud
Protection of purchasers from registered proprietor
Dealing with registered proprietor
Void instrument of transfer
Equities and unregistered interests
Priorities
Statutory invalidity of instrument executed without insertion of name of purchaser or transferee
The Real Property Act, 1861 to 1963 (Q.), ss. 33, 43, 44
The Real Property Act of 1877 (Q.), s. 48
The Stamp Act of 1894 (Q.), s. 53 (5)
The Real Property Act, 1861 to 1963 (Q.), ss. 33, 43, 44
The Real Property Act of 1877 (Q.), s. 48
The Stamp Act of 1894 (Q.), s. 53 (5).
Equity
Priority and notice
Priority generally

Legislative References:
Section 85 of the Land Transfer Act 1952 (N.Z.) - 44 (2); 183
Transfer of Land Act 1915 (Vict.) - 179

Case References:
Assets Co. Ltd. v. Mere Roihi - [1905] AC 176
Frazer v. Walker - [1967] 1 AC 569
Boyd v. Mayor, & c., of Wellington - (1924) NZLR 1174
Clements v. Ellis - [1934] HCA 18; 51 CLR 217
Mayer v. Coe - (1968) 88 WN (Pt 1) (NSW) 549
Ratcliffe v. Watters - (1969) 2 NSWR 146
Barry v. Heider - [1914] HCA 79; 19 CLR 197
Great West Permanent Loan Co. v. Friesen - (1925) AC 208
Rice v. Rice - (1854) 2 Drew 73 (61 ER 646)
Shropshire Union Railways & Canal Co. v. The Queen - (1875) LR 7 HL 496
Lapin v. Abigail - [1930] HCA 6; 44 CLR 166
Abigail v. Lapin - [1934] HCA 20; (1934) AC 491; 51 CLR 58
J. & H. Just (Holdings) Pty. Ltd. v. Bank of New South Wales - [1971] HCA 57; 125 CLR 546
Barry v. Heider - [1914] HCA 79; 19 CLR 197
Shaw v. Foster per Lord Cairns - (1872) LR 5 HL 321
Latec Investments Ltd. v. Hotel Terrigal Pty. Ltd. - [1965] HCA 17; 113 CLR 265
Caldwell v. Rural Bank of New South Wales - (1951) 53 SR (NSW) 415
Davies v. Ryan - (1951) VLR 283
Gibbs v. Messer - (1891) AC 248
Butler v. Fairclough - [1917] HCA 9; 23 CLR 78

Hearing date: 7, 8 June 1971
Judgment date: 13 December 1971

Sydney

---

Order

Appeal dismissed with costs.